Sony Ericsson S500 vs W580 pics

Walkman against emotional. Like I have said before Sony Ericsson managed to give unique identities to each of these phones. The S being stylish and the W being music centric and hip. After seeing these 2 phones side by side, I must say that I prefer the W580 look. The S500 looks a bit cheap in real life (the W580 doesn't suffer from this). Currently, my eyes are set on the grey W580. Which do you guys like better?

Pics from phonedaily